Old Lyme Homes under $1.25 million

Old Lyme Homes under $1.25 million

Welcome to Old Lyme, Connecticut – a hidden gem nestled along the picturesque shores of the Long Island Sound in New London County. This charming town boasts a rich history, stunning natural beauty, and a vibrant arts scene, making it an ideal destination for those seeking a tranquil yet engaging lifestyle.

Old Lyme is renowned for its beautiful landscapes, featuring serene beaches, lush parks, and scenic river views. The town's artistic heritage shines through in its numerous galleries, studios, and cultural events, attracting creatives and art enthusiasts alike. Stroll through the historic district, and you’ll find beautifully preserved colonial homes that tell the story of Old Lyme’s past, alongside modern amenities that cater to today’s residents.

For homebuyers seeking a slice of this idyllic town, Old Lyme offers a variety of homes priced under $1.25 million. Whether you’re looking for a cozy cottage by the water, a spacious family home surrounded by nature, or a charming historic property, you’ll find diverse options that cater to different tastes and lifestyles. Many of these homes feature stunning architectural details, expansive yards, and easy access to the town’s beautiful beaches and recreational activities.

With its welcoming community, top-rated schools, and an abundance of outdoor activities, Old Lyme is not just a place to live—it's a place to thrive. Explore the possibilities of calling this enchanting town your home, and discover why so many are drawn to the serene beauty and vibrant life that Old Lyme has to offer.

Newest Old Lyme Homes under $1.25 million

14 Haywagon Dr, Old Lyme
$1,195,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 24221383 MLS
Timeless elegance and exceptional craftsmanship define this Beach Farms property. Bordered by community open space along the side and rear, it offers privacy and tranquil marsh views. This handsome 4 bedroom, 3.5 bath home showcases custom millwork and updated interiors. A brilliant entry with a turned staircase and wainscoting opens to light-filled spaces with gleaming hardwood floors and impressive ceiling height. Enjoy formal living and dining rooms, a private office, and an open-plan kitchen with new appliances flowing into the great room and sunroom-ideal for family gatherings and entertaining. A main-level laundry/mudroom adds convenience. Front and rear staircases lead to four bedrooms, including a primary suite with a generous bath, cedar-lined closet and sitting area or second office with custom built-ins. Two bedrooms share a Jack-and-Jill bath; the fourth has a private ensuite. The large, daylight basement includes a workshop and incredible built in storage. The high ceiling and a four step bulkhead walkout lends to finishing! Professionally landscaped grounds feature a fenced garden and potting shed. An expanded southeast-facing deck is perfect for birdwatching, morning coffee and outdoor entertaining. Just steps from Old Lyme beaches, Beach Farms offers a premier neighborhood setting and a wonderful coastal lifestyle. Enjoy beautiful marsh views and the peace of mind of a home outside the flood zone. Simply perfect!

14 Haywagon Dr, Old Lyme

55 Rogers Lake Trl, Old Lyme
$535,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 24218581 MLS
Lake life! Discover this solid, well maintained mid-century home just one block to the lake. A propane heated, detached two-car garage/workshop with a separate (2026) 100-amp electrical panel will inspire every hobbyist/creator! This 3-4 bedroom home offers great space and an opportunity to add your personal style. The large, eat-in kitchen features pantry closets and an adjacent proper mudroom. The living room offers hardwood floors and a wood-burning fireplace. Find a main level primary bedroom, a full bath and an office with half bath, closet plumbed for washer/dryer (potential bedroom.) Upstairs there are two generous bedrooms, a comfortable den and a half bath with plenty of room to expand. The large basement offers more potential room to enjoy. Two sheds offer storage for kayaks and gardening equipment. A new roof was installed on the home and garage in spring 2026. Enjoy all that pristine, 260-acre Rogers Lake has to offer - 25+ access points for boating and swimming in crystal clear waters and fishing and ice fishing for bass, trout and pickerel. Three of the best lake access points are steps away- Tamiani Trail, Osceola and Devitt Loop. Find trailered boat access at the State boat launch. This is a terrific area for walking and biking. It's community with great traditions - the 4th of July Parade, boat parade and a clubhouse offers a great gathering spot. Don't miss this opportunity to make your mark on a very solid home and enjoy the best of lake life!

55 Rogers Lake Trl, Old Lyme

4 Green Valley Lake Rd, Old Lyme
$549,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 24208884 MLS
Welcome to 4 Green Valley Lakes in Old Lyme, where thoughtful updates meet the charm and lifestyle of one of Connecticut's sought-after shoreline communities. This well-maintained home features a new roof, offering added peace of mind for its next owner. Inside, beautiful hardwood flooring compliments the kitchen and bathroom, while recently updated landscaping enhances the home's curb appeal and welcoming feel. This raised ranch contains your expected comfort of every day living. The grounds allow for a garden enthusiast, an individual who needs to place their work vehicles, and/or one who wants to maximize on their privacy in a shoreline community. Beyond the property itself, Old Lyme offers the quintessential New England shoreline experience, known for its historic character, rich artistic heritage and beautiful natural surroundings. Long celebrated for its connection to American Impressionism, the town blends culture and history with the relaxed coastal lifestyle of the Connecticut River and Long Island Sound. Enjoy convenient access to Rocky Neck State Park, area beaches, boating, outdoor recreation, and the charm of Old Lyme's town center, well-sought-after schools, with local shops, dining and community amenities nearby. Whether you're searching for a year-round home or simply looking to embrace the Connecticut shoreline lifestyle, 4 Green Valley Lakes offers an inviting opportunity to enjoy the best of home, coast, culture and community.

4 Green Valley Lake Rd, Old Lyme

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website appears in part through the SMARTMLS Internet Data Exchange program, a voluntary cooperative exchange of property listing data between licensed real estate brokerage firms, and is provided by SMARTMLS through a licensing agreement. Listing information is from various brokers who participate in the SMARTMLS IDX program and not all listings may be visible on the site. The property information being provided on or through the website is for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers and such information may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Some properties which appear for sale on the website may no longer be available because they are for instance, under contract, sold or are no longer being offered for sale. Property information displayed is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. Copyright 2026 SmartMLS, Inc.

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!